Don't let errors on your Credit Report hurt your future opportunities. Learn More

Home / Negative Items / Credit Counseling vs Bankruptcy: Which Is Better?

Credit Counseling vs Bankruptcy: Which Is Better?

  • Struggling with overwhelming debt can be stressful and confusing.
  • Consider credit counseling for manageable debt or bankruptcy for severe debt situations.
  • Call The Credit Pros to get a free consultation and expert advice tailored to your financial needs.

Pull your 3-bureau report and see how you can identify and remove errors on your report.

Get Help From a Credit Expert

89 people started their credit fight today - join them!

BBB A+ rating credit repair company

Related content: Which is better: Chapter 7 or 13 bankruptcy Pros, cons & costs

Credit counseling and bankruptcy offer different debt relief paths. Credit counseling helps you manage debt through budgeting and negotiation. Bankruptcy discharges debts but hits your credit hard. Choose based on your debt, income, and long-term goals.

Credit counseling creates a debt management plan with little credit impact. It works best for manageable debt and steady income. Bankruptcy, through Chapter 7 or 13, suits overwhelming debt but sticks on your credit report for 7-10 years.

Need help? Give The Credit Pros a call. We'll chat for free, no pressure. We'll look at your 3-bureau credit report and suggest the best fix for you. Whether you need counseling or bankruptcy, we'll help you get financially free. Don't put it off - your money future's on the line!

On This Page:

    Credit Counseling Vs. Bankruptcy (Pros And Cons + Which Is Better)

    Credit counseling and bankruptcy offer different paths for dealing with overwhelming debt. Let's break down the pros, cons, and key differences:

    Credit Counseling:
    • You work with creditors to lower interest rates and waive fees.
    • You create a debt management plan (DMP) to consolidate payments.
    • Your credit score experiences minimal impact.
    • This option doesn't eliminate debt, it just makes it more manageable.
    • It's better if you have a steady income and manageable debt.
    • Costs are lower: typically $35 setup fee and $24 monthly fee.
    • Only 21% of consumers complete DMPs successfully.

    Bankruptcy:
    • Chapter 7 discharges most unsecured debts.
    • Chapter 13 creates a 3-5 year repayment plan.
    • Your credit suffers significant negative impact (7-10 years on report).
    • It provides more substantial debt relief.
    • It's necessary for insurmountable debt or limited income.
    • Costs are higher: around $4,000 including attorney fees.
    • Bankruptcy becomes public record.

    Which is better for you depends on your situation:

    • Choose credit counseling if you have manageable debt and steady income.
    • Opt for bankruptcy if your debt is overwhelming and your income is limited.

    We recommend exploring credit counseling first. It's less drastic and helps you avoid the long-term consequences of bankruptcy. However, if your debt is truly unmanageable, bankruptcy may be your best option for a fresh start.

    As a final point, we suggest speaking with a certified counselor to evaluate your financial situation and determine the most suitable path forward.

    Can Credit Counseling Help Me Avoid Bankruptcy

    Credit counseling can help you avoid bankruptcy by giving you strategies to manage your debt. You work with a counselor to review your finances, create a budget, and explore bankruptcy alternatives. The counselor might negotiate with creditors to lower interest rates or waive fees, aiming to create a sustainable repayment plan.

    However, credit counseling works best if you can make at least minimum payments and have manageable debt. For overwhelming debt or if you're already behind, bankruptcy might still be necessary.

    Benefits of credit counseling include:

    • Learning budgeting and money management skills
    • Potentially lowering interest rates and fees
    • Creating a structured repayment plan
    • Avoiding the long-term consequences of bankruptcy

    Remember, credit counseling is often required before filing for bankruptcy anyway. We recommend exploring all options with a certified credit counselor. They can help you understand if counseling will be enough or if bankruptcy is necessary.

    To put it simply, credit counseling can offer valuable tools and strategies to help you manage your debt, but it’s essential to assess your specific situation with a professional.

    How Does Credit Counseling Work For Debt Relief

    Credit counseling for debt relief involves working with a certified expert to assess your finances and develop strategies to manage debt. Here’s how it works:

    1. Initial consultation: You’ll have a free meeting with a counselor to review your income, expenses, debts, and credit report.

    2. Personalized plan: The counselor will offer tailored recommendations, which may include:
    • Budgeting help
    • Debt management plans
    • Debt consolidation options
    • Bankruptcy guidance (in severe cases)

    3. Creditor negotiations: Counselors often work with your creditors to lower interest rates or waive fees.

    4. Debt management plan (DMP): If appropriate, you’ll make a single monthly payment to the agency, which will distribute funds to your creditors based on negotiated terms.

    5. Ongoing support: You’ll receive education and guidance throughout the process to improve your financial habits.

    Key points to remember:
    • This approach is structured for long-term financial health, not a quick fix.
    • You’ll need to commit to budgeting and following a repayment plan for several years.
    • Choose reputable nonprofit agencies and compare services.
    • Be cautious of high fees or unrealistic promises.

    Credit counseling aims to help you avoid bankruptcy if possible, but it’s also required before filing for bankruptcy. This underscores its role in exploring all debt relief options.

    In short, by seeking credit counseling, you’re taking a positive step towards regaining control of your finances. Remember, you’re not alone in this journey, and there are solutions available to help you get back on track.

    Is Credit Counseling Required Before Filing Bankruptcy

    Yes, you need credit counseling before filing bankruptcy. You must complete it within 180 days before filing for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13. The course assesses your financial situation and explores alternatives.

    Key points:
    • You can complete counseling online, by phone, or in person.
    • Sessions typically last about an hour.
    • You'll discuss your finances and potential repayment options.
    • Even if you don't agree to it, a proposed plan must be filed.

    Exceptions exist for:
    • Incapacitation or disability.
    • Active military duty in combat zones.
    • Unavailable courses in your area (rare).
    • Exigent circumstances requiring immediate filing.

    To claim an exigent exception, you must prove you contacted an agency but couldn't complete counseling within 7 days. You'll still need to finish within 30 days of filing, with a possible 15-day extension.

    To find approved providers:
    1. Visit the U.S. Trustee’s website.
    2. Look for your court's jurisdiction.
    3. Choose a provider from that list.

    To finish, remember that completing counseling doesn't obligate you to follow any proposed plan. It's a necessary step to ensure you explore all options before filing for bankruptcy.

    Inaccuracies hurting your Credit Score?
    Securely review your full 3-bureau Credit Report (with a real expert).

    By clicking ‘Get Started’ I agree by electronic signature to: (1) be contacted by The Credit Pros by a live agent, artificial or prerecorded voice, and SMS text at my residential or cellular number, dialed manually or by autodialer even if my phone number is on a do-not-call registry (consent to be contacted is not a condition to purchase services); and (2) the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

    What Debts Can Be Eliminated Through Bankruptcy Vs. Counseling

    You have two main options to handle your debts: bankruptcy or credit counseling. Chapter 7 bankruptcy can eliminate most unsecured debts like credit cards, medical bills, and personal loans, but won't touch child support, alimony, recent taxes, or most student loans. Chapter 13 involves a 3-5 year repayment plan. Credit counseling, on the other hand, won't erase your debts but helps with budgeting, potentially lowering interest rates or fees. It often uses debt management plans to consolidate your payments without reducing the owed amount.

    Costs can vary significantly. Bankruptcy filing and attorney fees can exceed $4,000, while credit counseling typically has lower setup and monthly fees. Bankruptcy hits your credit harder but offers a fresh start for those who qualify. Conversely, counseling preserves more options and flexibility.

    Here are some key differences:
    • Bankruptcy can discharge many debts; counseling doesn't eliminate debt.
    • Bankruptcy has higher upfront costs but may provide more relief.
    • Counseling impacts your credit less and offers more flexibility.
    • Bankruptcy eligibility depends on your financial situation.

    Your choice depends on the debt amount, types of debt, income, and your long-term goals. We recommend evaluating your specific circumstances and consulting professionals to determine the best approach for your situation.

    In essence, you need to consider your financial situation and long-term goals to determine whether bankruptcy or credit counseling is the better option for managing your debts.

    What Are The Main Types Of Bankruptcy For Individuals

    The two main types of bankruptcy for individuals are Chapter 7 and Chapter 13.

    You can file for Chapter 7, known as liquidation bankruptcy, if you have limited income or assets and can't repay your debts. This involves selling non-exempt assets to pay creditors and discharging the remaining eligible debts. The process takes about 4-6 months to complete.

    Chapter 13, called reorganization bankruptcy, allows you to keep your assets while repaying debts through a 3-5 year court-approved plan. This option is good for those with regular income who want to catch up on missed payments. It stops foreclosure and repossession actions and may discharge some debts that are not eligible under Chapter 7.

    Key factors you should consider include:
    • Eligibility requirements
    • Which debts can be eliminated
    • Impact on your credit
    • Assets you can protect
    • Length of the process
    • Long-term financial consequences

    We recommend consulting a bankruptcy attorney to assess your situation and determine the best option. They can help you weigh pros and cons and explore alternatives like credit counseling before filing.

    To wrap up, understanding your options and seeking professional advice can help you make informed decisions regarding bankruptcy.

    Are There Eligibility Requirements For Counseling Or Bankruptcy

    Yes, you must meet specific eligibility requirements for both credit counseling and bankruptcy. For credit counseling, you need to:

    • Complete an approved session within 180 days before filing for bankruptcy.
    • Use an agency approved by the U.S. Trustee Program.
    • Obtain a certificate of completion to file with your bankruptcy petition.

    The counseling session usually takes 1-2 hours and can be done online, by phone, or in person. It will cover your finances, budgeting, and alternatives to bankruptcy.

    For bankruptcy eligibility:

    • Chapter 7 requires you to meet income thresholds and pass a means test.
    • Chapter 13 requires you to have sufficient regular income for a repayment plan.
    • Both types need you to complete pre-filing credit counseling.
    • You must also complete a post-filing debtor education course.

    If you file for Chapter 7, you submit the debtor education certificate within 60 days of the creditors' meeting. For Chapter 13, you have until your final plan payment.

    Exceptions to these requirements are rare and usually apply only in emergencies or if approved courses aren't available in your area. On the whole, completing all required steps ensures your bankruptcy filing goes smoothly.

    What Are The Costs Of Credit Counseling Vs. Bankruptcy

    Credit counseling usually costs less upfront than bankruptcy. Nonprofit agencies often provide free initial consultations. If you enroll in a debt management plan, you can expect setup fees of $25-$75 and monthly fees around $25-$50. These plans aim to lower interest rates and consolidate payments over 3-5 years, potentially saving you money in the long term. However, you will still repay your full debt amount.

    Bankruptcy has higher initial costs but may offer more substantial relief. For Chapter 7, fees usually total about $1,500-$4,000, which includes:

    • Court filing ($335)
    • Mandatory credit counseling ($50-$100)
    • Attorney fees ($1,000-$3,500)

    Chapter 13 costs are similar but are spread over a 3-5 year repayment plan. While more expensive upfront, bankruptcy can eliminate unsecured debts entirely (Chapter 7) or reduce your overall debt burden (Chapter 13). However, it will severely impact your credit score for 7-10 years, limiting your future financial options.

    You should carefully weigh these costs against your debt amount and long-term financial goals. Credit counseling might work better for manageable debts, while bankruptcy could provide a fresh start for overwhelming financial situations. Bottom line: consider speaking with a financial advisor to determine the best path for your unique circumstances.

    Inaccuracies hurting your Credit Score?
    Securely review your full 3-bureau Credit Report (with a real expert).

    By clicking ‘Get Started’ I agree by electronic signature to: (1) be contacted by The Credit Pros by a live agent, artificial or prerecorded voice, and SMS text at my residential or cellular number, dialed manually or by autodialer even if my phone number is on a do-not-call registry (consent to be contacted is not a condition to purchase services); and (2) the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

    Which Option Impacts My Credit Scores Less

    Credit counseling impacts your credit scores less than bankruptcy. Here's why:

    1. Bankruptcy's harsh impact:
    • Chapter 7 stays on your report for 10 years.
    • Chapter 13 remains for 7 years.
    • Both can drop scores by 200+ points.

    2. Credit counseling's milder effect:
    • Typically reported as "enrolled in debt management."
    • May lower scores initially, but less severely.
    • Allows for positive payment history as you repay debts.

    3. Long-term considerations:
    • Bankruptcy's negative impact lessens over time.
    • Credit counseling can help rebuild credit faster.
    • With counseling, you're seen as taking proactive steps.

    4. Lender perceptions:
    • Bankruptcy is a major red flag for future credit.
    • Counseling shows you're addressing financial issues responsibly.

    5. Recovery potential:
    • Post-bankruptcy, credit rebuilding takes years.
    • With counseling, you can see score improvements sooner.

    Remember:
    • Your specific situation affects the impact.
    • Both options have pros and cons beyond credit scores.
    • Consider speaking with a financial advisor for personalized guidance.

    At the end of the day, credit counseling offers a gentler path for your credit scores compared to the more drastic effects of bankruptcy.

    How Does Bankruptcy Affect Future Borrowing

    Bankruptcy significantly impacts your future borrowing abilities. After you file, it stays on your credit report for 7-10 years, severely damaging your credit score. This makes getting new credit tough and expensive. Lenders see you as high-risk, often leading to loan rejections or unfavorable terms like higher interest rates and bigger down payments.

    But don't lose hope! You can rebuild credit post-bankruptcy. Here's what we suggest:

    • Use secured credit cards responsibly.
    • Make timely payments on all debts.
    • Keep credit card balances low.

    Over time, as bankruptcy ages on your report, you'll likely see better loan opportunities. Most people qualify for conventional loans within 2-3 years after discharge, though interest rates may still be higher than those with clean credit histories.

    Lastly, remember that bankruptcy gives you a fresh start. While it affects borrowing short-term, responsible financial management can help you bounce back stronger. We're here to support you through this journey to better financial health.

    How Long Does Each Process Take

    Credit counseling typically takes 1-2 hours for the initial session, with ongoing support lasting months or years. Bankruptcy timelines vary: Chapter 7 usually takes 4-6 months from filing to discharge, while Chapter 13 involves a 3-5 year repayment plan.

    The credit counseling process usually includes:
    • A 1-2 hour initial consultation
    • Developing a debt management plan
    • Regular check-ins with your counselor
    • Ongoing budget adjustments as needed

    For Chapter 7 bankruptcy:
    • 2 weeks to prepare paperwork
    • 15 days after filing for creditors to receive notice
    • About 1 month later, creditors' meeting occurs
    • 60 days for creditors to object to debt discharge
    • 90 days from filing for discharge order (in simple cases)

    Chapter 13 bankruptcy involves:
    • 2 weeks to prepare petition and repayment plan
    • 3-5 years to complete court-approved repayment plan
    • Final discharge after plan completion

    Delays may occur due to:
    • Complex financial situations
    • Incomplete documentation
    • Creditor objections
    • Court backlog

    We recommend you consult a bankruptcy attorney to get a personalized estimate based on your specific circumstances. They can guide you through each step and help minimize delays. Finally, remember that professional guidance ensures you navigate each process efficiently and with confidence.

    Privacy and Cookies
    We use cookies on our website. Your interactions and personal data may be collected on our websites by us and our partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions